Comments on blogs irk me, but not for the reason you probably are thinking right now. There are two kinds of blogs, those with comments and those without. There are places for both, but blogs that posture an opinion should probably have comments and those comments should not be deleted because you disagree with that person’s stance.

For example, it seems that one of the favorite pastimes of A-list bloggers is to constantly complain about Twitter’s well documented outages. I don’t understand this behavior. If it doesn’t work, wouldn’t you find something that does?

This comment got my attention:

“Anyway, I'd like to really understand what's going on behind the scenes at Twitter, Inc. They say they're confident the new infrastructure will hold up better, I'd like to understand why. Can we have a meeting, with a few people from the tech community who actively use Twitter and a few people from the company, to be briefed on what's going on. The same way the President briefs Congress when there's some kind of international crisis.”

So I simply commented, “Why would you think Twitter owes you an explanation?”

To which I got the reply “…watch your accusatory tone.”

Hmm, I’ve already put them on the defensive, so I soften my reply a bit: “How is that accusatory? I just don’t think that a company is going to accept that they owe you something…” (or something very close to this).

Moments later, I was deleted – the entire thread I started with a simple question, was gone.

Further research seems to indicate that this particular person is notorious for this behavior. I don’t understand how a blog with comments is supposed to work when the only view is the unilateral one. I have a huge amount of respect for Jeff Atwood because of the simple reason that he makes bold statements based on research and then lets the comments come to life. More than half do not follow his reasoning, but that’s where the magic is – based on all this back and forth, I’m getting the story and then I’m hearing opposing arguments all in one thread.

My only recourse was to unsubscribe from those who would not open comments up to opposing views. I simply can’t trust what they have to say any longer. I voice unchecked is not something I am willing to listen to – if you are doing this, you are just shouting at me and to that I say, “no thanks”.